The blackout action on the Internet today (ranging from mostly complete blackouts on sites like Wikipedia and certain Tumblr blogs to conspicuous messages on Google and Wired) seem to have made a dent in the anti-piracy legislation currently working through Congress. The Washington Post reports that at least six lawmakers have withdrawn their support for the House (SOPA) and Senate (PIPA) versions of the bill.
Among other things, it’s been a fascinating study in public relations. As Sharon Waxman puts it in an article over at Reuters, the technology industry found a simple message that resonated with the general public, and they pressed it - hard. They were late to the game (the RIAA, MPAA and the rest of the content industry were quietly moving on this back in the early fall), but when the Internet community finally decided to move, it shifted the tide quickly and decisively. And while their legislation burned in the streets of public opinion, Hollywood fiddled with a press release.
Waxman’s article is dead-on. Regardless of which side you think is right, Hollywood and the broader content industry demonstrated today that it has no idea how to communicate with the public in the 21st century.
Speaking of which side is right or wrong - and in the interests of full disclosure - this ad guy sides with Silicon Valley. Yes, the ad biz is a creative industry, and our agency definitely makes our living on intellectual property. Piracy is a problem. However, as one of my favorite web cartoonists puts it, the current legislation is a lot like trying to deal with an escaped lion from the zoo by blasting a basket of kittens with a flamethrower. I’m pretty sure there are more efficient ways of addressing the problem (and avoid kitty barbeques, too).